Update time! A lot has happened since I got my "grail"
Executive summary:
* Bought a Gayle Bradley Air (that was dyed red!)
* Bought 2 Southards (one stock, other LSCF)
* Bought a Michael Walker lightweight
* Bought a Black/Satin ParaMilitary 2
* Bought a Black/Black Tenacious
* Almost bought a Large CF Sebenza and a Sebenza 25
* Handled a CF ZT0560 S110V
* Handled a Manix
* Handled a Manix XL
* Handled a Titanium Southard
* Handled a Sage 3
* Lost my Blue Para 2 to the TSA
* Sold the CF S90V ParaMilitary 2
* Sold the Rookie
* Sold the Native 5
* Selling the Michael Walker
And now some details...
* Bought a Gayle Bradley Air (that was dyed red!)
- I really love this knife. It's small like a Rookie, but it has a liner lock and flow-through design. M4 steel is cool too, but I am a little concerned about rust (nothing so far)
* Bought 2 Southards (one stock, other LSCF)
- The stock one came with an STR deep carry clip that I promptly caught on a door frame the very next day and bent out of shape :-O. Luckily, I sent it back to Steve and he sent me (I think) a brand new one. AWESOME!
- The LSCF one has a very thin LSCF scale installed PLUS the original G-10 scale that was dyed black. Both scales are very cool, but the LSCF is pure heaven! Because it's thinner, the whole knife is about the same thickness as a Para 2, and the profile is slimmer than a Para 2 because of the lack of a "spydie hump". It flips out smoothly with both the flipper and the spydie hole.
- I noticed that the LSCF Southard was a lot stiffer opening than the stock and Titanium one (see below), so I went investigating. What I found was that the bearing cage was slightly too big inside the cavity in the handle, which prevented it from being able to spin around freely. I sanded down the edges of the bearing cage, and that made it slightly smaller and able to spin around freely, and now it is super smooth!
(Picture of the Southard bearing cage inside the cavity of the handle)
* Bought a Michael Walker lightweight
- I was curious about this one. Actually, I knew Cosmo was selling a CF Michael Walker, so I wanted to get a feeling for the size before I jumped in and grabbed the more luxurious version. It turns out that it's not that compelling to me, mostly because the blade is too short. For that size, I prefer the Air because at least the Air's carry size is smaller and packs a bigger blade.
(it's no match for the Rookie!)
* Bought a Black/Satin ParaMilitary 2
- After losing my Blue Para 2 to the TSA (more on that below), I felt like I needed a replacement Para 2 that wasn't as expensive as the CF S90V one. They popped up on Howe's and I ordered 2. I kept the smoother one and sold the one that had a little bit more sticky lock. However, with my love affair with the LSCF Southard, I don't think there is any real reason to have this Para 2, especially when the Green Para 2's drop sometime hopefully soon!
* Bought a Black/Black Tenacious
- Was curious about this one too. On paper, it fits all my criteria. Good blade length, shorter handle, not a backlock. However, I could really tell the difference between a China produced Spyderco and a Taiwan/USA produced Spyderco. The blade is off-center, the lockup is very late, and it just isn't very smooth. I think this one is almost certainly going to go.
* Almost bought a Large CF Sebenza and a Sebenza 25
- When I had Sebenzas, I didn't like the Insingo blade on the Large, and I didn't like its weight. So lately I've been thinking about trying a Large CF Sebenza. One came up for sale and I made an offer but it wasn't accepted so this is probably a mixed blessing. The one thing I've found after having Sebenzas and Benchmades is that I just plain don't like thumbstuds!
- The same seller was also selling a Sebenza 25. It's new, it's a Sebenza, so I just wanted to play around with it. Almost certainly, I wouldn't like it because it has thumbstuds and it's heavy (>5 oz) but.... it's new, and it's a Sebenza and I wanted to play with it :). Again, the seller didn't accept my offer so I'm $400 richer now...
* Handled a CF ZT0560 S110V
- I'm helping out someone overseas who wants to proxy some knives through me, so I get to handle some interesting variants that I'd probably never purchase for myself. I was very curious about the Zero Tolerance ZT0560 with Carbon Fiber scales and S110V steel :-O and he happened to order it. I tried it out and found why I would never have ordered one myself. Too long, too thick, too heavy. Just not my style.
* Handled a Manix
- Surprisingly enough, after all these different Spydies that I've handled, I've never seen a plain old Manix 2. It's very much like the Manix lightweights that I've had except definitely more beefy. I think I actually could get used to carrying one with a deep carry clip, I do like the lock, the size, and the ergonomics. I just wish that it was FFG in a production blade (I know the sprints have FFG, but not the stock version).
* Handled a Manix XL
- Wow, this sucker is as large as it seems on paper! I cannot imagine carrying this around!
* Handled a Titanium Southard
- Titanium scale on a Titanium knife seems like overkill, but this was really nice! The Ti scale definitely makes the whole handle a lot thicker, but very ergonomic. Probably puts it in the same class as the Benchmade Grip/Mini Grip in terms of ridiculously thick handles. Very cool.
(Titanium vs. Stock scale)
(LSCF vs. Stock scale)
* Handled a Sage 3
- Again, I've had a Sage 1 and Sage 2, but never a Sage 3. It was definitely the least impressive of the 3. Kind of like a smaller Manix, the ball bearing lock is smoother than the Manix but the blue G-10 felt cheap and I didn't like the fact that it is not a flow-through handle.
* Lost my Blue Para 2 to the TSA
- I already posted the full story (http://www.spyderco.com/forums/showthread.php?59225-Most-expensive-knife-lost-to-the-TSA), but the jist of it is that I was taking my Blue M390 Para 2 on a trip and had it in my check-in baggage. At the last minute I needed to reduce the weight of the bag under 50 pounds and accidentally pulled the knife out of my check-in bag and put it into my carry-on bag. Not enough time to go back through security meant the Para 2 went bye-bye. It was a very sad day, and it still peeves me everytime I think about it.
* Sold the CF S90V ParaMilitary 2
- A combination of a sticky lock (which I tried to fix, but to no great avail) and the fact that it was worth just way too much money, and because I just lost a significant investment in my Blue Para 2 led me to sell my former "grail." It was made easier by the fact that I fell in love with the LSCF Southard, so I could let the Para 2 go.
* Sold the Rookie
- This was a hard decision, but I just wasn't carrying it. I have found that I really don't like backlocks, and for small knives I prefer the Air, so the Rookie had to go.
* Sold the Native 5
- Ok, so I said I don't like backlocks, but the Native 5 is really something special. I love the feel of it, beefy handle and a choil for different positions. The backlock is unlike many of the others, because it has less friction on opening, and swings freely closed when you depress the lock. If not for the fact that the blade is just too short, I would have probably kept this one.
So now my final inventory of keepers is:
* Manbug G-10
* Gayle Bradley Air
* Salt 1 PE
* Caly 3.5
* LSCF Southard flipper
* ParaMilitary 2 Black/Satin
* Pacific Salt SE
What next?
* Well, I need to finally sell the Walker and my extra Southard, and maybe even the Para 2 because the Green Paras are coming soon. Then I'll be down to 6, close to my magic number of 5. The Caly 3.5 may be next on the chopping block, but it was my first real knife so it has a sentimental value that we'll see if I can get past :)
GearPull
Titanium CF beads
A Kukri, Root, & Finger
Pocket Dump Time!
One grail gone, and one grail arrived
Leather for the entire family
Thank You Tony and Creepo!!
Knife GAW